This page is now archived. Below please find a list of every production selected as a “critic’s pick” from 2017 to 2021. Enjoy!
BROADWAY
Musicals
"Ain’t Too Proud"
"The Band’s Visit"
"Beetlejuice"
"Carousel"
"Chicago"
"Come from Away"
"Dear Evan Hansen"
"Hadestown"
"Hamilton"
"Mean Girls"
"Oklahoma!"
"Once on this Island"
"The Prom"
"SpongeBob SquarePants"
"West Side Story"
Plays
"All My Sons"
"Angels in America"
"A Soldier’s Play"
"The Children"
"Choir Boy"
"Derren Brown: Secret"
"Farinelli and the King"
"The Ferryman"
"Harry Potter and the Cursed Child"
"The Inheritance"
"Ink"
"Junk"
"Latin History for Morons"
"The Nap"
"Network"
"The New One"
"Slave Play"
"Straight White Men"
"Three Tall Women"
"To Kill a Mockingbird"
"Torch Song"
"Travesties"
"The Waverly Gallery"
"What the Constitution Means to Me"
OFF-BROADWAY
Musicals
"A Strange Loop"
"Brigadoon"
"Darling Grenadine"
"Desperate Measures"
"Enter Laughing"
"Fiddler on the Roof in Yiddish"
"Grand Hotel"
"Little Shop of Horrors"
"Mack & Mabel"
"Midnight at the Never Get"
"Octet"
"Oklahoma!"
"Ordinary Days"
"Smokey Joe’s Cafe"
"Soft Power"
"Sweeney Todd"
"Woody Sez"
"The Wrong Man"
Plays
"Admissions"
"All Is Calm: The Christmas Truce of 1914"
"The Amateurs"
"America is Hard to See"
"A Midsummer Night’s Dream"
"THE AЯTS"
"A Streetcar Named Desire"
"Black Light"
"By the Way, Meet Vera Stark"
"Caesar & Cleopatra"
"Collective Rage: A Play in Five Betties"
"The Damned"
"Dance Nation"
"Describe the Night"
"Do You Feel Anger?"
"Dr. Ride’s American Beach House"
"Everyone’s Fine with Virginia Woolf"
"Good Grief"
"Hangmen"
"Harry Clarke"
"Hundred Days"
"In the Body of the World"
"jazz singer"
"Judgment Day"
"Julius Caesar"
"Killing An Evening with Edgar Allan Poe"
"The Last Match"
"The Light"
"Make Believe"
"Mary Page Marlowe"
"The Metromaniacs"
"The Michaels"
"Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow Moscow"
"The Mother"
"Nassim"
"Paradise Blue"
"Pass Over"
"Pipeline"
"Plot Points in Our Sexual Development"
"The Portuguese Kid"
"Private Peaceful"
"queens"
"The Rolling Stone"
"School Girls, or the African Mean Girls Play"
"Skin"
"Slave Play"
"Sugar in Our Wounds"
"Tiny Beautiful Things"
"Toni Stone"
"Too Heavy for Your Pocket"
"Twelfth Night"
"Usual Girls"
"What the Constitution Means to Me"
"Wives"
"Yerma"